Showing posts with label Buenos Aires. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Buenos Aires. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 18, 2024

Viceroyalty of the Río de la Plata: British Preparations for the Invasion of 1806

Preparation of the English Invasions



May 3, 1803. In the British legation building in Paris, the lights burn late at night. The ambassador, Lord Charles Whitworth, makes final preparations to leave the French capital. The war between his country and France is already a practically accomplished fact. Once again the two great powers will launch into the fight, to decide, in a last and gigantic clash, which will exercise supremacy in the world.

Shortly before midnight a French government official arrives at the embassy. He brings an urgent message from the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord. He asks Whitworth for an interview that should take place the following afternoon, and in which matters of extreme importance will be discussed. The British ambassador believes he discovers a ray of hope in the request. It is still possible, at the last moment, to preserve peace.


William Pitt, Prime Minister of Great Britain, and Napoleon, Emperor of France. They dispute the domination of the world. Engraving from 1805

At the appointed time the meeting takes place. Talleyrand, bluntly, presents his proposal: Napoleon Bonaparte offers Great Britain an honorable exit. The center of the dispute, the island of Malta, a strategic key to the Mediterranean, will be evacuated by the British forces that occupy it. But when the British withdraw, Malta will be under the control of Russia, a country that will have to guarantee that the island does not serve the war interests of France or England. Whitworth listens attentively to the Minister, and then, without hesitation, gives his response:

-Mr Minister, my country considers Malta as a key position for its security. Our troops must, therefore, remain on the island for a period of no less than ten years...

Talleyrand, avoiding a specific response, incites the ambassador to transmit Napoleon's proposal to the London cabinet. Master in the art of persuasion, Talleyrand achieves his goal. Whitworth leaves the Minister's office determined to support the negotiation. Whether war is avoided depends on it.

May 7, 1803. The British cabinet, chaired by Henry Addington, Viscount of Sidmouth, studies Whitworth's office with the French proposal. The discussion is brief. For British Ministers there is no possibility of compromise. The offer only constitutes, in his opinion, a new ploy by Napoleon to gain time until his fleet, which is in the Antilles, reaches the European coast. Addington then issues a final order, which must be immediately transmitted to the embassy in Paris: the proposal is rejected. The French must accept, as the only way out, that the English forces remain in Malta for a period of ten years. If they refuse, Whitworth must leave Paris within thirty-six hours.

The die, for the British, is cast. On the night of May 11, Napoleon gathers his governing council at the Saint-Cloud palace. He has the British note in his hands, and makes it known to the Ministers. A dramatic silence follows his words. A vote is then taken to decide the issue. Of the seven members of the council present, only Talleyrand and Joseph Bonaparte oppose starting the fight. The war is finally underway.

On May 18, the British government officially announces the start of hostilities. On that same day the first meeting takes place. An English frigate, after a short cannonade, captures a French ship near the coast of Brittany. From that moment on, and for more than ten years, peace will no longer reign in Europe. Within the whirlwind of events generated by that conflict, the American emancipation movement will take place.

The war that begins soon engulfs Spain as well. At first the King, Charles IV, and Manuel Godoy, his Prime Minister, try to stay out of the fight, evading the obligations of the alliance with France. To this end, and as a price for their neutrality, they offer Napoleon the signing of a treaty by which they undertake to give him a monthly subsidy of 6,000,000 francs. Napoleon, already working feverishly on organizing the invasion of England, accepts the deal. However, the British are determined to prevent Spain from sustaining a “half-war”, and will force it to define itself.

On May 7, 1804, William Pitt (son), the “pilot of the storms,” once again assumed the leadership of the English government. Eleven days later Napoleon takes the title of Emperor of the French. The two men who symbolize the will to predominance of their respective nations are thus confronted. For Pitt, the time has come for the final clash, and he is determined to maintain an all-out fight until he achieves absolute victory. Napoleon and his empire must be destroyed, so that the “European balance” that will allow Great Britain to continue its aggrandizement without hindrance is restored. Thus, upon receiving the Spanish ambassador in London, he categorically told him:

- The nature of this war does not allow us to distinguish between enemies and neutrals... the distance that separates both is so short that any unexpected event, any mistrust or suspicion, will force us to consider them equal.

This veiled threat soon translated into concrete aggression. The pretext is given by the reports sent by Admiral Alexander Cochrane, pointing out the concentration of French naval forces in Spanish ports. On September 18, 1804, the English government sent Admiral William Cornwallis, head of the fleet blocking the French port of Brest, the order to capture the Spanish ships that, coming from the Río de la Plata, took the flows to Cádiz. from America. Cornwallis immediately detaches four of his fastest frigates to set out in pursuit of the Spanish ships.


The British Ambassador in Paris, Lord Charles Witworth, facing Napoleon.

On October 5, 1804 the meeting took place. Advancing through the fog, the English ships intercept their prey twenty-five leagues off Cádiz. A brief and violent combat then ensues, during which one of the Spanish frigates, the "Mercedes", explodes and sinks. On board her, Mrs. María Josefa Balbastro y Dávila, wife of the second chief of the Spanish flotilla, Captain Diego de Alvear, perished. The latter, who travels on the frigate “Clara”, saves his life along with that of his son, Carlos María, the future General Alvear, warrior of Argentine independence.

The fight ends with the surrender of the three Spanish ships that escape destruction. These ships, loaded with more than 2,000,000 pounds of gold and silver bars, are taken to the port of Plymouth. This is the first blow of the English, and provokes a violent reaction in Spain. In Great Britain itself, the unexpected attack gives rise to a strict condemnation by Lord William Wyndham Grenville, who does not hesitate to declare:

 -Three hundred victims murdered in complete peace! The French call us a mercantile nation, they claim that the thirst for gold is our only passion; "Do they not have the right to consider that this attack is the result of our greed for Spanish gold?"
The coup against the frigates, however, is nothing more than the beginning of a series of attacks that follow one another quickly. Off Barcelona, ​​Admiral Nelson captures three other Spanish ships; and in the waters of the Balearic Islands, English ships attack a military convoy and capture an entire regiment of Spanish soldiers that is heading to reinforce the garrison of Mallorca. In the face of aggression, Spain cannot fail to respond with war. That is precisely what Pitt intends.

October 12, 1804. In a luxurious country mansion located on the outskirts of London, an interview is held that will have decisive consequences for the future of the Río de la Plata. Prime Minister William Pitt, Henry Melville, First Lord of the Admiralty, and Commodore Home Popham are gathered there.

The fight against Spain is already, for the British leaders, a reality, even though the rupture of hostilities has not yet been finalized. The meeting, therefore, aims to analyze possible plans of action against the Spanish possessions in America. That's why Popham is there. He, together with Francisco Miranda, has worked intensely on the development of projects aimed at operating militarily on American lands to separate the Spanish colonies from the metropolis. Pitt and Melville listen attentively to Popham's reports and agree with his intentions. One point, however, worries Pitt. He wishes to be assured that, should the planned war against Spain fail to break out, Miranda will not carry out the operation. Popham responds categorically:

 -Miranda, who I know very well, will never violate his commitment. He will respect his pledged word to the end. In this way the discussion concluded. Popham received the order from his superiors to draft the project in detail and present it to Lord Melville within four days.

Thus was born the famous “Popham Memorial”, the starting point of the British attack on Buenos Aires in June 1806. Upon receiving the news, Miranda met with Popham and, using documents and maps, proceeded with him to complete the memorial. . The main objective was Venezuela and New Granada, where Miranda intended to disembark and raise the cry for independence. Popham, in turn, introduced a secondary operation into the project, directed against the Viceroyalty of the Río de la Plata, which he would attack using a force of 3,000 men. He also proposed that troops brought from India and Australia act in the Pacific against Valparaíso, Lima and Panama. Miranda would command the forces operating in Venezuela, and Popham would take charge of the expedition against Buenos Aires.

The purposes of the plan were clearly defined: the idea of ​​conquering South America was completely ruled out, since the objective was to promote its emancipation. It was contemplated, however, "the possibility of gaining all its prominent points, establishing some military possessions." The American market, in turn, would be opened to British trade.

On October 16, punctually, Popham and Miranda presented the memorial to Viscount Melville. He found it satisfactory, but he refrained from expressing a definitive opinion about the realization of the project, since England was facing a very serious threat at that time, which forced it to concentrate all its forces. On the other bank of the English Channel, in the military camp of Boulogne, Napoleon had enlisted an army of almost 200,000 soldiers. The emperor was determined to carry out what seemed impossible: the invasion of the British Isles. “Since it can be done... it must be done!” he had stated, in categorical order, to his Minister of the Navy. At the instigation of this directive, in all the ports of the French coast the shipyards worked feverishly on the construction of thousands of vessels destined to ensure the passage of the army through the channel. In one of his dispatches, Napoleon clearly defined his unshakable resolve:

“Let us be masters of the canal for six hours, and we will be masters of the world!”

The danger of a French landing was, therefore, imminent.

Within the climate of extreme alarm created by this situation, it was inevitable that Popham and Miranda's plans would be put aside. Another no less important fact came together to contribute to the definitive postponement of the planned expeditions. Russia began negotiations with the British government to form a new coalition of European powers against Napoleon. However, as a condition of that alliance, Tsar Alexander I demanded that an attempt be made to also attract Spain to the coalition. Pitt was thus forced to suspend all action against the American colonies.

That attitude was maintained even after Spain had formally declared war on Great Britain on December 12, 1804. The insistent complaints that Miranda sent to Pitt were of no use. He remained imperturbable, and informed the Venezuelan general that the political situation in Europe had not yet reached the degree of maturity necessary to begin the enterprise.

It is the month of July 1805. Miranda, completely disillusioned by the failure of his efforts, decides to leave Great Britain and go to the United States, where he trusts that he will receive help to carry out the emancipation crusade. Popham, in turn, has lost all hope. He is serving in the port of Plymouth, far from London and his contacts with the senior leaders of English politics. For that adventurous man, inaction, however, cannot be prolonged.

Secret reports thus come to their knowledge about the weakness of the forces defending the Dutch colony of the Cape of Good Hope, at the southern tip of the African continent. This news is enough for the sailor to conceive a new and daring undertaking. He without delay heads to London, and there he meets with one of the members of the cabinet. For Popham it is necessary, and this is what he states, to take advantage of the extraordinary opportunity that is presented and, through a surprise attack, take over the aforementioned colony.

Finding out, Pitt decides to immediately launch the operation. This time, unlike what happened with the American projects, the prime minister does not show any hesitation. Without a doubt, the Cape of Good Hope constitutes a vital point for Great Britain, as it dominates the maritime communication route with its possessions in India. For the English, it is essential that this strategic position does not fall into the hands of the French, who are known to have deployed naval forces in the South Atlantic.


William Pitt Portrait

On July 25, 1805, the pertinent instructions were sent, under the label of "very secret", to General David Baird, who had been appointed head of the attack forces. Six infantry regiments and one cavalry regiment, with a total of almost 6,000 soldiers, are assigned to the expedition. Popham receives command of the escort flotilla, made up of five warships.

Four days later, Popham has a final interview with Pitt. The sailor has, meanwhile, received new and confidential reports. A powerful merchant from London, Thomas Wilson, informed him that he had positive news that Montevideo and Buenos Aires were practically unguarded, and that a force of a thousand soldiers would be enough to achieve the conquest of both places.

In the conversation he has with Pitt, Popham informs him of the data indicated. The prime minister, however, tells the commodore that, in view of the position adopted by Russia, which demands that Spain be drawn into the ranks of the coalition against Napoleon, he cannot authorize any hostile action against the American colonies. He concludes, however, with a statement that will have a decisive influence on Popham's subsequent behavior. These were Pitt's words:

 -Despite this, Popham, and in case the negotiations we are carrying out with Spain fail, I am determined to re-adopt your project.
Thus, the Commodore left to join his ships, convinced that it would not be long before Pitt sent him the order to attack Buenos Aires. When embarking in Portsmouth on his flagship, the “Diadem”, Popham carries in his luggage a copy of the memorial that, in October 1804, he wrote together with Francisco Miranda. The plan, after all, will have to be carried out as soon as the favorable opportunity arises.

November 11, 1805. The population of the Brazilian port of Bahia gathers at the docks and witnesses the unexpected arrival of the British expeditionary force. Popham goes ashore and obtains there, in addition to the water and food he needs for his squad, new reports that confirm those he has already received in London. The Río de la Plata lacks sufficient military forces to resist an assault carried out with determination and audacity. An Englishman who has just arrived in Bahia from Montevideo does not hesitate to declare to Popham: "If the attack is carried out, the same inhabitants of the city will force the Spanish garrison to capitulate without firing a single shot..."

When Popham leaves the Brazilian coast and heads towards the Cape of Good Hope, he has practically already decided to try the enterprise. The only thing left now is for the situation in Europe to take the necessary turn for the London authorities to abandon their refusal to carry out the attack.

The news of the English fleet's landfall in Bahia soon spread. Alarm is spreading in Buenos Aires, and Viceroy Rafael de Sobremonte mobilizes all forces to face the invasion, which he considers imminent. In the United States, in turn, the newspapers, based on rumors and erroneous reports, anticipate events and, four months before the British troops disembark in the Río de la Plata, publish the news that Buenos Aires it has already been conquered by Popham and Baird.

The aggression, however, was not yet to occur. Deviating from the American coasts, the English headed to the Cape of Good Hope, where they arrived in the first days of January 1806. The conquest of the colony was easily achieved, after defeating the Dutch forces in a short combat. The mission was thus accomplished. Popham, impatient, then waits for reports from Europe, ready to launch himself into the Río de la Plata as soon as circumstances allow it.

In the month of February, reports of the extraordinary victory obtained by Admiral Nelson at Trafalgar reach the commodore. The fleets of France and Spain have been eliminated as combative forces, in a day of fighting that definitively ensures the supremacy of Great Britain on all the seas. But this triumph was counteracted, shortly afterwards, by the crushing defeat that Napoleon inflicted on the Austrian and Russian armies in Austerlitz. The news of this last battle was obtained by Popham on March 4, 1806, through the crew of a French frigate that the English captured off the Cape of Good Hope.

A concrete fact arises, however, from these two events. Spain has been definitively linked to her alliance with Napoleon, and there is no longer any possibility of attracting her to the ranks of the coalition that, practically, has ceased to exist. Popham, therefore, is at liberty to carry out his plans.


Henry Melville, First Lord of the Admiralty.

The commodore then decides to act. Thomas Waine, captain of the “Elizabeth”, a North American slave ship that has made several trips to Buenos Aires and Montevideo, confirms the news about the weakness of the forces defending both places. Therefore, there is no need to waste any more time. On April 9, Popham sends a letter to the admiralty in which he communicates that he has decided not to remain inactive in Cabo, since all danger has already disappeared there, and that he leaves with his ships to operate on the coasts of the Río de la Plata.

The next day Popham sets sail, but shortly afterwards he must interrupt sailing when the wind dies down. He then takes advantage of the circumstance to resolutely demand that General Baird support his plans, providing him with a contingent of troops. The reports from the American captain and those he obtains from an English sailor who has lived eight years in Buenos Aires serve as a powerful argument in the discussion he has with his colleague. Finally, Baird, convinced that nothing will stop Popham in his adventure, decides to give him the support he requests.

The attack on Buenos Aires is thus resolved. On April 14, 1806, Popham's ships set sail from Cape Town, escorting five transports carrying more than 1,000 soldiers, commanded by General William Carr Beresford. A veteran of many campaigns, Beresford is, because of his resolve and courage, the right man to attempt the plan. As the main assault force, the British leader has the troops of the brave 71st Scottish Regiment.

For six days the fleet sails without problems, heading west. On April 20, however, a violent gale breaks out and the ships disperse, losing contact with one of the troop transports. Popham, to cover the loss, heads to the island of Saint Helena, where he requests and obtains a reinforcement of almost 300 men from the British governor. Before leaving the island, the sailor sends a last letter to the admiralty to justify, once again, his behavior. To that note he attaches the famous memorial that, in 1804, he presented to Pitt. This is proof that the expedition does not respond to an improvised decision, but is the result of a plan already studied by the British government. The conquest of Buenos Aires, Popham points out, will give the English possession of the "most important commercial center in all of South America."

Then the long journey begins. A frigate, the “Leda”, ahead of the bulk of the fleet and sails quickly towards the American coasts, with the mission of reconnoitring the terrain. The appearance of that ship, which appears before the fortress of Santa Teresa, in the Banda Oriental, on May 20, 1806, gives the first alarm to the authorities of the Viceroyalty.

June 13, 1806. For five days the British fleet has been in the waters of the Río de la Plata. Popham and Beresford are now reunited aboard the frigate “Narcissus,” along with their top lieutenants. The two British leaders have convened a war meeting to make a final decision on what the target of the attack will be. Until that moment, Beresford has maintained the convenience of occupying Montevideo first, since this place has powerful fortifications that will be very useful for the reduced invading force, if there is a violent reaction from the population of the Viceroyalty. Popham, however, is determined to attack Buenos Aires directly, and has an extraordinarily convincing argument in his favor. Thanks to the reports of a Scotsman, who was traveling on a ship captured by the English a few days before, it is known that the royal funds destined to be sent to Spain are deposited in Buenos Aires. The prospect of getting hold of the treasure finally dispels all doubts. Furthermore, the conquest of Buenos Aires, capital of the Viceroyalty, will have, in Popham's opinion, a much greater influence on the mood of the colony's population than the capture of the secondary outpost of Montevideo. With extreme audacity, the British sailor thus decides to risk everything for everything.

June 22, 1806. At dusk, a Spanish ship anchors in the port of Ensenada de Barragán, a few kilometers east of Buenos Aires. The ship's commander brings alarming news that will soon reach the knowledge of Viceroy Sobremonte. The English ships are heading towards Ensenada, which indicates that the attack will be launched against the capital of the Viceroyalty. Sobremonte, upon receiving the report, immediately ordered the sending of reinforcements to the eight-gun battery located in La Ensenada, and appointed the naval officer Santiago de Liniers to take charge of the defense of the position. Liniers leaves without delay to assume the new command.

From that moment on, events accelerate. On June 24, and with the arrival of new reports that indicate the appearance tion of the English ships in front of the Ensenada, Sobremonte launches a decree summoning all men capable of bearing arms to join the militia corps within three days. Despite the seriousness of the situation, that night the Viceroy attends, along with his family, a performance held at the Comedias theater. His apparent serenity, however, will soon fade completely.

In the middle of the performance, an officer bursts into the Viceroy's box bringing urgent documents sent by Liniers from Ensenada. The English, that morning, had just carried out a landing feint, bringing eight boats loaded with soldiers closer to land. The attack, however, did not materialize, prompting Liniers to point out in his office that the enemy fleet is not made up of units of the English Royal Navy, but rather “despicable privateers, without the courage and resolution to attack, their own.” of the warships of every nation.”

Sobremonte, however, does not participate in the Liniers trial. He immediately leaves the theater, without waiting for the performance to end, and quickly goes to his office in the Fort. There he drafts and signs an order providing for the concentration and readiness of all defense forces. In order not to cause alarm in the city, which sleeps oblivious to the imminent danger, he orders that the regulatory cannon shots not be fired, and sends parties of officers and soldiers to verbally communicate the mobilization order to the militiamen.

Thus arrives the morning of June 25th. In front of Buenos Aires, the English ships appear in line of battle. In the Fort the cannons thunder, raising the alarm, and extreme confusion spreads throughout the city. Hundreds of men come from all the neighborhoods to the barracks, where weapons and equipment have already begun to be distributed, in the midst of terrible disorder.

Shortly after 11 o'clock, and to the surprise of Sobremonte, the enemy ships set sail again and set course towards the southeast. The Viceroy believes that the English have given up the attack. Soon, however, she comes out of his delusion. From Quilmes the alarm cannon resounds, announcing that the landing has begun there.

At noon on June 25, the first British soldiers set foot on land on Quilmes beach. The landing operation continues without any opposition for the rest of the day. Men and weapons are carried in an incessant coming and going to land, by twenty boats. As night falls, Beresford inspects his men under a cold drizzle that soon turns into a heavy downpour. There are only 1,600 soldiers and officers, and they have, as their only heavy weapons, eight artillery pieces. However, this small force is made up of professional combatants, for whom war is nothing more than a job. Veterans of a hundred battles, they are determined, like their boss, to take by storm a city whose population exceeds 40,000 inhabitants. That is the order, and they will have to comply with it, facing any risk.

With the arrival of day, Beresford orders his troops to prepare for the attack. At eleven o'clock the drums begin their roll, and the flags are displayed in the wind. From the top of the ravine facing the beach, the deputy inspector general of the troops, Colonel Pedro de Arce, sent by Sobremonte to contain the English, observes the movement of the enemy forces. With a measured step, and accompanied by the martial airs of the bagpipers, the British advance towards the swamp that separates them from Arce and his 600 militiamen. The latter, armed with a few carbines, swords and chuzas, grouped behind the three cannons with which they intended to repel the British assault.


Advance of the English troops on Buenos Aires, at the moment of crossing the Riachuelo. English engraving of the time.

The clash, under these conditions, can only have one result. Marching through the grasslands, the companies of the 71st regiment resolutely climb the ravine and, despite the defenders' volleys, they gain the crest and overwhelm them, putting them to flight.

From that moment on, chaos breaks out in the defense forces of Buenos Aires, made up almost entirely of militia units lacking any military training. The leadership fails, in the person of Sobremonte, who, overwhelmed by the defeat of his vanguards, only manages to feign a weak attempt at resistance on the banks of the Riachuelo. He concentrated troops there and burned the Gálvez Bridge (current Pueyrredón Bridge) which, from the south, gives direct access to the city. That position, however, will not be sustained. Already on the afternoon of the same day, June 26, Sobremonte met with Colonel Arce, and clearly told him that he had decided to retreat inland.

Beresford, on the other hand, acts with all the energy that circumstances demand. After the battle of Quilmes he only gave his troops two hours of rest, and then tenaciously set out to pursue the defeated enemy. He fails, however, to arrive in time to prevent the destruction of the Gálvez Bridge, but, on June 27, he subjects the defenders' positions on the other bank to violent cannonade, and forces them to retreat. Several sailors then jump into the water and bring boats and rafts from the opposite bank, in which a first assault force crosses the current.

This is how you gain a foothold. Beresford then orders an improvised bridge to be immediately built, using boats, and the rest of his troops quickly cross the Creek. Nothing will now be able to prevent the British advance on the center of the capital city of the Viceroyalty.

Sobremonte has witnessed, from the rear, the actions that culminate with the abandonment of the Gálvez Bridge position. At that moment he was in charge of the cavalry forces which, with the arrival of reinforcements from Olivos, San Isidro and Las Conchas, numbered nearly 2,000 men. He avoids combat, however, and begins the retreat towards the city along the "long street of Barracas" (current Montes de Oca avenue).

Those who are not aware of the Viceroy's plans assume that the purpose of this movement is to organize a last resistance in the center of Buenos Aires. However, upon reaching the "Calle de las Torres" (current Rivadavia), instead of heading towards the Fort, Sobremonte turns in the opposite direction and leaves the capital. His hasty march, to which his family soon joins, will continue in successive stages until finally concluding in the city of Córdoba.

Meanwhile, a frightful confusion reigns in Buenos Aires. From the Riachuelo the militia units flow in disorganized groups, who, without practically firing a single shot, have been forced to withdraw, after the retreat of the Viceroy.

The Fort then becomes the center of the events that will culminate with the capitulation. The military leaders, the officials of the Court, the members of the Cabildo and Bishop Lué are gathered there.

Totally dejected, after receiving the news of Sobremonte's withdrawal, the Spanish officials await the arrival of Beresford to surrender the plaza. They have the impression that, in the most difficult hour, the head of the Viceroyalty and representative of the monarch has abandoned them.

Shortly after noon, a British officer sent by Beresford arrived at the Fort, with a Parliament flag. He expressed that his boss demanded the immediate surrender of the city and that the resistance cease, pledging to respect the religion and property of the inhabitants.

The Spanish did not hesitate to accept the summons, limiting themselves to setting out a series of minimum conditions in a capitulation document that they sent to Beresford without delay. Thus, Buenos Aires and its 40,000 inhabitants are handed over to 1,600 Englishmen who have only fired a few shots.

Popham's audacious coup has fully paid off. The city is in their hands, and the British have only had to pay, as the price for the extraordinary conquest, the loss of one dead sailor. The remaining casualties of the Invasion forces only amount to thirteen wounded soldiers and one missing.

Beresford now marches resolutely on the Fort. On the way he receives the written conditions of capitulation sent to him by the Spanish authorities. The general only stops his progress for a few minutes, to read the documents, and then authoritatively states to the bearer of the document:

-Go and tell your superiors that I agree and will sign the capitulation as soon as the occupation of the city ends... Now I can't waste any more time!

At 4 in the afternoon the British troops arrive at the Plaza Mayor (current Plaza de Mayo), while heavy rain falls on the city. The English soldiers, despite their exhaustion, march martially, accompanied by the music of their band and their pipers. General Beresford tries to give the maximum impression of strength and has arranged for his men to march in spaced columns. The improvised ruse, however, cannot hide from the sight of the population the small number of invading troops that appear before the Fort.

The British General, accompanied by his officers, then enters the fortress, and receives the formal surrender of the capital of the Viceroyalty. The next day, the English flag flies over the building. For forty-six days, the banner will remain there as a symbol of an attempt at domination that, however, will not come to fruition.

Indeed. Neither of the two British bosses considers the company to be finished. Despite the formal compliance that the authorities give them, they know that indignation spreads among the people when they verify that the city has been captured by a simple handful of soldiers.

The resistance, which will not take long to organize, can only be faced through the arrival of the reinforcements that Beresford and Popham rush to request from the London government.

Historiador del País

Tuesday, August 8, 2023

1955 Revolution: Peronist Mobs Burn Catholic Temples



View of the High Altar of San Francisco


The Temples Burn


Original source: 1955 Guerra Civil. La Revolucion Libertadora y la caída de Perón



On the night of June 16-17, 1955, Peronist mobs assaulted and set fire to the historic temples of Buenos Aires in retaliation for the aerial bombardment


The terrible violence unleashed that day did not stop after the fighting. The reader will remember that around half past four in the afternoon, bands of exalted Peronists rushed into the Metropolitan Curia to sack and burn it, a fact that General Ernesto Fatigatti witnessed when he passed through the place, in the heat of the fight.

The mob destroyed objects of enormous artistic and cultural value and, along with them, the Historical Archive, with its old documents from the 16th, 17th, 18th and 19th centuries, "a unique and irreplaceable treasure", in the words of Isidoro Ruiz Moreno.



A woman cries before the desolation in San Francisco (Courtesy Fundación Villa Manuelita)


On that chaotic day, invaluable pieces of art and historical artifacts belonging to the city of Buenos Aires were tragically lost forever. The chaos ensued when the Curia building caught fire, and in the midst of the turmoil, a mob appeared, carrying off sacred objects, precious artistic vestments, ancient chalices, ciboriums, monstrances, patens, habits, and cassocks. These individuals then proceeded towards the main temples of the city with the clear intent of vandalizing them.

Two groups marched towards the convents of Santo Domingo and Nuestra Señora de la Merced. At Santo Domingo, the religious witnessed the arrival of agitators in trucks who, upon passing the temple, displayed aggressive gestures and shouted curses against the Church. In fear of an imminent attack, the friars and seminarians hurried to secure the doors and windows, but due to the escalating situation, they eventually had to evacuate under the guidance of their prior, Fray Luis Alberto Montes de Oca, who was deeply concerned for their safety. Despite the difficulties in communication caused by the cut telephone lines, Fray Luis chose to remain at the convent as its custodian.



Another vandalized altar in San Francisco

At 5:30 p.m., a frenzied crowd surged toward the gates blocking the atrium's access, while some individuals attempted to enter through the windows on Calle Defensa by breaking the bars. The devoted religious had no option but to hastily disguise themselves in civilian attire and escape through a small door in the 5 de Julio passage, blending in with the chaotic mob.

The historical temple, which held the tomb of General Manuel Belgrano and other iconic figures from the country's history, suffered merciless destruction and burning. This sacred place held invaluable cultural treasures, including the banners captured from royalists during battles in Salta and Tucumán, as well as from the British during the invasions of 1806 and 1807, along with precious artworks, images, and religious artifacts. Despite Fray Luis's attempt to seek help from the 2nd Police Station, the authorities responsible for maintaining public order did nothing to contain the savagery.

Two blocks away, at the corner of Defensa and Alsina, the San Francisco church and the adjoining chapel of San Roque also caught fire. This was the place where General Lavalle had been appointed governor of Buenos Aires in 1828.

Inside the convent's oratory, Fray Cecilio Heredia, along with fifteen other religious, was offering prayers of gratitude for Perón's call for calm when a deafening commotion from outside startled them. The terrifying noise of the mob invading the temple grounds and the sight of the friars fleeing through a side door in civilian clothes shook the cloisters. Fray Cecilio managed to escape but remained nearby, deeply saddened to witness the convent and church consumed by flames.

Just a short distance away, a similar scene unfolded at the church of San Ignacio, the oldest building in the city, connected to the historic Colegio Nacional (formerly known as Colegio Real de San Carlos, the birthplace of heroes). The enraged mob, armed with heavy objects, violently assaulted the grand doors and hurled insults at the religious and the Church as a whole.



This is how the ceilings of the Curia chapel appeared after the incident:

Father Alberto Lattuada, the parish priest, was engrossed in reading in his room when the sound of screams reached his ears. He rushed to the staircase and witnessed the crowd breaking through the porticoes, storming inside with shouts and raised clubs. The Jesuit bravely confronted them, raising his arms in a plea for calm and reason, urging them not to carry out an attack they would regret.

As Father Alberto attempted to restrain the vandals, he felt someone forcefully grabbing his arm and dragging him away. It was a young blond boy who shook him violently, forcing him outside amidst blows and insults. The boy threatened him with lynching if he dared to stay in the vicinity.

Outside, Father Alberto spotted two Army trucks filled with soldiers parked near the church. Desperate for help, he ran towards them, only to receive a disheartening response that left him paralyzed. "We cannot intervene. Seek out the officer in charge," they said.

Deeply disturbed, the parish priest helplessly witnessed the ruffians removing sacred images and objects from the temple and throwing them onto the street while the flames started to engulf the interior. Nearby, Lieutenant priest Guillermo Sáenz observed the scene with a heavy heart. The old convent, which held the tomb of Juan José Castelli and was once the grand "Jesuit empire of the Missions," as described by Leopoldo Lugones, began to crumble under the onslaught.

When the initial acts of violence unfolded, Perón and his associates were gathered at the Ministry of the Army. From there, they saw the smoke and the glow of the first bonfires, realizing the catastrophe unfolding in the city center. The Justicialist leader, seated at a table, stood up and exclaimed indignantly:

-Take action immediately because these are communist gangs that are burning the churches, and then they are going to attribute it to me!
The president had barely finished speaking when Lucero urgently called General José Embrioni to inform him about the need to take immediate measures to protect the historical temples and threatened buildings. Embrioni contacted the police chief, who, remembering Minister Borlenghi's directive to keep the force stationed against potential attacks from revolutionary civilian commandos, decided to remain in place and take no action. He firmly believed that the Army would handle the situation.

Perón made a mistake by attributing responsibility to the communists because the attackers of the churches were actually his own supporters, driven by the fury and hatred he himself had incited.

At 6:30 p.m., the fire crews finally left their barracks and rushed to extinguish the fires. Upon arriving at Santo Domingo, Fire Commissioner Rómulo Pérez Algaba witnessed the burning of the Santeria and the altars, fueled by benches set on fire by the protesters.

Pérez Algaba also noticed an overturned tanker truck from which people were taking gasoline to add to the flames. He witnessed thugs smashing sacred images and objects on the pavement, stealing piggy banks, and desecrating ballot boxes containing relics of the heroes. Despite his attempts to communicate with his superiors, the vandals prevented him from doing so.

As he was on site, four individuals dressed in raincoats approached Pérez Algaba and warned him that flags captured from the English and Spanish were inside the temple, and four men were trapped in the library. They urged him to act swiftly to rescue them. Pérez Algaba responded firmly:

-Just as they came in let them come out. As for the flags... that's another thing.

The officer, accompanied by several firemen, ventured into the ruins, their path illuminated by a flashlight. Fortunately, they reached the site just in time to rescue the trophies and safeguard them. The glass covering had miraculously kept the trophies intact, protecting them from destruction. They swiftly retrieved the items and withdrew, narrowly escaping a collapsing column that would have obliterated everything.

During the rescue, Pérez Algaba and two of his men sustained injuries. These courageous individuals deserve the gratitude of posterity for safeguarding these invaluable pieces of our history.

Pérez Algaba and his team members were evacuated, but the four looters, equipped with chandeliers, remained inside. They broke the bars on the windows and daringly jumped from the first floor at the corner of Venezuela and Defensa.

Meanwhile, San Francisco was engulfed in flames on all sides. The firefighters had to engage in hand-to-hand combat with the protesters to halt the destruction. It was a spectacle to behold as burning pieces of wood detached from the central dome, plummeting onto the streets and sidewalks.

At Nuestra Señora de la Merced, the mob attacked and set fire to the left side of the temple. The flames spread to the sacristy, and thick smoke filled the central nave. In contrast, Nuestra Señora de la Piedad was also targeted, but the spilled kerosene did not ignite, thanks to the intervention of neighbors and law enforcement officers who managed to neutralize the threat. Nevertheless, the looting had devastating consequences, and things could have been much worse if the firefighters hadn't arrived in time to extinguish the fire that the protesters had started in the library for the blind on the mezzanine.



A different perspective of the High Altar at the Basilica of San Francisco is shown.

San Miguel endured minimal damage in the central nave, but the sacristy and rectory were ablaze when a team led by Commissioner Severo Toranzo arrived and thwarted a second attack.

Similarly, San Nicolás de Bari, situated on Santa Fe Avenue, suffered destruction as looters set the church on fire and threw valuable artistic and religious objects from the second-floor balconies. The attackers had to escape through side exits to avoid being trapped. It's worth noting that the church was originally founded in 1733 by the Spanish Domingo de Acassuso at its original location on 9 de Julio and Av. Corrientes, where the obelisk now stands [2].

The most severe damage occurred at Nuestra Señora de las Victorias, located on Paraguay and Libertad. The mob started a small fire and ransacked everything within reach. Both the parish office and the sacristy were in flames when a member of the parish movement named Marcó Bonorino and an unidentified lady attempted to douse the fire using water from vases. Another individual, named Cullen, alerted the police that several individuals had entered the priestly rooms, overturned a kerosene stove to start a fire, and stolen the collection money stored there.



The destruction at the Belgranian Institute was heartbreaking.

When the violence reached its peak, the parish priest, RP Jacobo Wagner, bravely attempted to intervene and stop the criminals. However, the attack he endured was so brutal that he was left unconscious on the ground. He remained in a prostrate state for forty-five days before tragically succumbing to the injuries inflicted on him.

Other Peronist groups targeted various churches, including San Juan Bautista located in Piedras y Alsina, where the fifth viceroy of the Río de la Plata, Don Pedro Melo of Portugal and Villena, is buried. Our Lady of Mercy and Our Lady of Help, the latter being associated with the drama of Camila O'Gorman [3], also suffered a similar fate.

Militants from the Basic Unit situated on Av. Corrientes and Jorge Newbery attempted to set fire to the church located on Osorio and Warnes. However, they were apprehended in time and detained for further investigation at Section 29.

That day, a devastating wave of destruction engulfed several other important temples including the Metropolitan Curia, Nuestra Señora de la Merced, San Ignacio, San Francisco, San Roque, Santo Domingo, San Juan Bautista, San Nicolás de Bari, Nuestra Señora de las Victorias, San Miguel Arcángel, Nuestra Señora del Socorro, and La Piedad. The fires reddened the low clouds that covered the Buenos Aires night, as described by Ruiz Moreno. But it wasn't only churches that were attacked; other institutions like the Belgraniano Institute, the Brotherhood of Nuestra Señora del Rosario, the Reconquest and Defense Commission, and the Pious Union of Blessed Martín de Porres, adjacent to Santo Domingo, also suffered destruction and fire.

Disturbing images circulated globally, showing the vandals wreaking havoc in the temples and parading around at night wearing stolen priestly garments and holding stolen objects. These actions brought shame to the Argentine people and tarnished their tradition. In a matter of hours, the country lost invaluable treasures of its artistic, historical, and religious heritage.

Miguel Ángel Cavallo offers a description of the events in Bahía Blanca on the night of June 16. Following the failure of the uprising, groups of workers assembled in front of the regional CGT building to hear their leaders' speeches and then marched in columns to the main square, armed with sticks, chains, and stones, prepared to attack the Cathedral. Once inside the city's main temple, they forced open its large doors and proceeded to destroy altars, images, and internal rooms. They even toppled the Carrara marble baptismal font and set parts of the interior on fire. Similar to the events in Buenos Aires, the mob donned clerical clothing, singing and dancing in the streets while chanting obscene and insulting verses.


A parishioner seeking solace in prayer (Courtesy Fundación Villa Manuelita)

Subsequently, the protesters rushed to the Corazón de María church and then to Nuestra Señora de Lourdes, causing similar damage. They continued their rampage by attacking the newsroom of the newspaper "Democracia," a courageous opposition publication led by Luis E. Vera. They wreaked havoc on their offices, destroying furniture, machinery, and facilities, before igniting another fire.

The vandals concluded their destructive spree at the headquarters of the Radical Civic Union, which they also set ablaze. Afterward, they retreated through the streets, singing chants in support of their leader. Surprisingly, neither the firefighters nor the police intervened, and there was no official acknowledgment of the events the following day. The newspaper "Democracia" was shut down, its owner detained and held incommunicado, along with the priests from the churches and religious schools of the city, who were transferred by trucks to the headquarters of the 5th Infantry Regiment [4].

Isidoro Ruiz Moreno provides an approximate estimate of the losses incurred on that fateful day. Commissioner Rafael Pugliese, head of the 2nd Section, discovered the urn containing the remains of General Zapiola lying behind the mausoleum of General Belgrano at the Santo Domingo convent. The urn had been forcefully removed from the Virgin's dressing room.



Anguish and despair gripped the porteños as they endured fateful hours. Their city was first bombed, and immediately after, their historical, cultural, and religious heritage was devastated, as described by the Courtesy Fundación Villa Manuelita.

In the atrium, antique furniture, some of which had been lent by the convent for the Cabildo Abierto meeting on May 22, 1810, was set ablaze. The main altar and two other sides of the church were consumed by the fire, while several others suffered severe damage.

Nearly all the precious images were removed from their rightful places, either thrown to the ground or set on fire. Crystals and stained glass windows were shattered with stones, and the colonial furniture and historical organ in the choir were consumed by the flames. The Venetian majolica of the vaults was destroyed, and the dressing room of the Virgen del Rosario, where the banners seized from the English in 1806 and 1807, and those captured by General Belgrano from the Spaniards during the campaigns of the North, was demolished. Numerous trophies displayed in the side wall showcases vanished.

The sacristy suffered the same fate, reduced to ashes, with its cabinets set on fire, and the two Carrara marble baptismal fonts smashed into pieces. Internal halls and a minor chapel in the eastern sector were also burned. The priests' rooms were ransacked, their furniture destroyed, and the prior's room was set on fire.

San Ignacio's altars were ruthlessly destroyed, with wood torn from them, and others caught fire, along with smashed furniture. The vandals even set fire to the church's library and the parish priest's room, demolishing the crockery, sideboards, and a grand mirror with a console.

In the chapel of San Roque, the altars were set ablaze, and the linings of the vaults and richly decorated side walls crumbled to pieces. The main images were also destroyed. Nearby, San Francisco faced a similar tragic fate, with all its ancient and artistic altars, including the largest one, lost to the flames. The dome collapsed, leaving only its metal skeleton standing, and precious stained glass windows fell into pieces. The fire devoured extremely valuable paintings and furniture from the 18th and 19th centuries. The presbytery, sacristy, carvings, images, and sacred objects were thrown viciously about, and rooms and dependencies of the convent were engulfed in flames. Priceless chalices, candelabras, monstrances, crucifixes, and other valuables were stolen, many of them made of silver and solid gold, adorned with precious gemstones. Among the ruins, the great 1.50-meter tabernacle stood out, tossed amidst rubble and the remains of charred objects.

In one night, Buenos Aires lost four centuries of history, leaving the city in mourning over its irreplaceable heritage.


Dome and roofs of the ruined Cathedral


Looters attack the Tabernacle in the Cathedral

Absorbed faithful observe the destruction in the Curia

Library and Archive of the Curia destroyed by fire


The great dome of San Francisco victim of the flames

The altar of San Francisco desecrated

The people of Buenos Aires observe in disbelief the desecration of their temples, in this case San Francisco


More destruction in San Francisco


State in which the ceilings of San Francisco were left

Vandalized benches and imagery in San Francisco

San Francisco side altar

San Francisco. Access to the convent


High Altar of San Francisco


Side altar of the Basilica Nuestra Señora del Rosario (Convent of Santo Domingo)


Convent of Santo Domingo. Side view of the High Altar


Ruins and rubble in the church of San Ignacio


Saint Joseph beheaded in San Ignacio


Monsignor D'Andrea's room in San Miguel Archangel burned down

San Miguel Arcangel. Another image of the state in which Monsignor D'Andrea's room was left


Ruins in the Church of San Juan Bautista, tomb of Viceroy Pedro Melo of Portugal and Villena


Notes

  1. Antonio González Balcarce, Martín de Alzaga, Juan de Lezica y Torrezuri and the general José María Zapiola.
  2. Miguel Ángel Cavallo, Puerto Belgrano, Hora 0. La Marina se subleva, Cap. III “El 16 de junio en Bahía Blanca”.
  3. Isidoro Ruiz Moreno, op. Cit., Tomo I, Tercera Parte, Cap XI, “La cruz en la hoguera”.
  4. Between 1935 and 1936 it was moved to its current location and it houses the marble font in which Bernardino Rivadavia, Bartolomé Miter and San Héctor Valdivielso Sáez, the first Argentine saint, were baptized, as well as pieces of sacred art of inestimable value, something that the scoundrel was completely unaware.
  5. In a niche of the latter lie the remains of Santa Constancia Martyr, victim of the persecutions of Nero, sent from Rome when it was elevated to a basilica.

Monday, July 31, 2023

1955 Revolution: The Attack on the Metropolitan Cathedral

Attack on the Cathedral *


Original source: Guerra Civil 1955. La Revolución Libertadora y la Caída de Perón

   
Assault on the Metropolitan Curia (Courtesy: Fundación Villa Manuelita)

On November 10, 1954, Perón initiated a forceful campaign against the Catholic Church, accusing it of meddling in national politics and inciting opposition to the government. During a lengthy plenary session at the Presidential House in Olivos, he announced his new cabinet members, legislators, union representatives, and leaders from various Peronist organizations. In a speech that lasted several hours, Perón pointed fingers at the Curia for fueling opposition and attempting to destabilize the government. He singled out numerous priests and religious figures, including the bishops of Córdoba and Santa Fe, alleging that they were agitators. Furthermore, he unveiled a series of measures aimed at neutralizing the Church's influence.

The president's actions caused widespread confusion among the population, and even within his own ruling regime, as many initially believed his words were merely rhetoric. However, in the days that followed, it became evident that Perón intended to wage an actual war against the Church.

In this context, Perón presented Law No. 14,394 to Congress, which included the provision for divorce. Additionally, he advocated for the Prophylaxis Law, which encouraged the establishment of brothels and the suspension of religious education in schools. Perón's measures also encompassed banning all processions and ordering the closure of the Catholic newspaper "El Pueblo," founded by Father Federico Grote on April 1, 1900.

When May 1955 marked the end of Catholicism as the official state religion, the public perceived it as the onset of a new era of violence and persecution in Argentina.

On April 25 of the same year, the government entered into a controversial oil contract with Standard Oil Inc. Co. of California, granting them special concessions in the distant governorate of Santa Cruz, including exploitation rights and extraterritorial privileges. This decision was a stark departure from Perón's consistent ten-year rhetoric against the United States, and it was seen as a "surrendering" move, a term that would later be widely used by his opponents a decade later.

The implementation of these new measures created an extremely tense atmosphere in Buenos Aires. Religious persecution, something unprecedented in Argentine society at that time, intensified when the government of La Rioja prohibited the traditional procession with the images of San Nicolás de Bari and the Niño Alcalde, a longstanding practice. This was accompanied by an increase in arrests and layoffs in the public sector. On March 21, 1955, the government passed a law that removed several religious dates from the official calendar, including All Saints' Day, All Souls' Day, Saint Peter and Saint Paul, the Immaculate Conception, and Corpus Christi, replacing them with partisan events, the main one being "Loyalty Day" on October 17. Eduardo Vuletich, general secretary of the CGT, expressed to a crowd gathered in Plaza de Mayo on May 1: "We workers prefer someone who speaks to us in our language rather than one who prays in Latin, facing the altar and turning their back on the people!"

The hostilities continued, and after a massive act where Perón implied that the clerical leadership "had to leave," the Chamber of Deputies abolished the oath "For God and on the Holy Gospels," repealed religious teaching, enacted the Prophylaxis Law, and imposed heavy taxes on Catholic institutions. When the Episcopate read a pastoral letter in churches on April 17, referring to the ongoing events, several priests and Catholic militants were arrested, leading some regime officials to resign in the following days. Slowly, the regime began to show signs of internal division.

The day of the Corpus Christi procession arrived, which since the second foundation of Buenos Aires had been taking place annually in Plaza de Mayo, with the city authorities following the Blessed Sacrament under a canopy, to the Cathedral.

The celebration had been prohibited under Law 14,400, which also designated it as a "Working Day," enabling employers to deduct pay from employees who didn't attend work. Despite this, Catholic groups defiantly worked tirelessly to ensure the event took place.

Recognizing their determination, the government attempted to limit the commemoration to the Cathedral, hoping to quell the fervor. However, this measure failed to deceive the Catholics, who remained undeterred and mobilized their forces to conduct the procession as they had done for centuries. It marked the first time the seemingly invincible Peronist government faced open opposition.

The situation prompted an urgent meeting between government officials and Church representatives. Present were the Minister of the Interior, Ángel Borlenghi; the Minister of Foreign Relations and Worship, Julio Atilio Bramuglia; the Chief of Police, Miguel Gamboa; and representatives of the Metropolitan Curia, including Monsignors Manuel Tato and Ramón Novoa. The government urged the Church not to proceed with the event, citing concerns about potential violence that might be difficult to prevent. However, these arguments did not intimidate the Catholic congregation in the slightest.

On June 11, 1955, at approximately 3:00 p.m., thousands of men, women, and children gathered in front of the Metropolitan Cathedral to partake in the ceremony. Under the leadership of Monsignor Antonio Rocca, the vicar general, the procession carried the Blessed Sacrament under a canopy while the crowd passionately sang religious hymns. It was a truly awe-inspiring demonstration of faith and determination.


Corpus Christ Procession (Gentileza: Fundación Villa Manuelita)

After the evening mass concluded at 6:00 p.m., a lengthy procession of faithful believers proceeded down Avenida de Mayo towards the National Congress, singing the National Anthem and inviting more people to join along the way. Repeatedly, they chanted slogans like "Christ yes, another no," "Catholic Argentina," "Perón or Christ," "Freedom," and "We are also a people." When they reached Congress, the demonstrators stayed for a while before gradually dispersing in various directions. However, some small groups of agitated militants began shouting anti-government slogans and vandalized a plaque near one of the torches on the building, which commemorated Mrs. Eva Perón lighting the flame on October 18, 1950, the Year of the Liberator General San Martín. Another militant threw two plaques inside the building through the large iron doors. Additionally, they graffitied the walls of Av. Callao and Rivadavia with phrases like "Get out Nero," "Christ wins," and "Zoo Nacional," and painted a large cross over the "V" for victory. Despite these incidents, the group eventually withdrew without further disturbances.

However, the situation didn't end there. Commissioner Gamboa had covertly infiltrated individuals into the demonstration with the aim of causing disruptions. Capitalizing on the fervor and passion of the protesters, these infiltrators proceeded to destroy the windows of the confiscated newspaper "La Prensa" and uttered insults against Perón, Evita, the CGT, and the official newspaper "Democracia." They also vandalized the windshields of some cars. Later that night, militants from the Alianza Libertadora Nacionalistas, members of the General Confederation of Labor, and some members of the Peronist police smeared the statues of Sarmiento, Alberdi, Roque Sáenz Peña, and Rivadavia. They also defaced the fronts of the embassies of Israel and Yugoslavia, and later destroyed a vehicle belonging to the embassy of Peru. State Radio spread false information that the religious demonstration had been small in number but highly aggressive, falsely attributing the excesses to elements unrelated to the demonstration.

The worst incident unfolded the following day when the newspapers, led by "Democracia," emblazoned the headline "BETRAYAL" and reported on the burning of the national flag by "clerical mobs."

According to their accounts, "They set the flag of the Homeland ablaze and raised the flag of the Vatican State at Congress. Clerical groups, led by priests in cassocks, not only offended Evita but also vehemently targeted the CGT and the UES. They resorted to violence by shooting at Democracia and La Prensa, committing a series of grave excesses." "El Laborista" also chimed in, stating: "They burned our flag. Oligarchic clerical elements fomented riots in the city, turning against the people." These views were echoed by other media outlets, all known for their sycophantic stance towards the government.

A distressing photo of Perón, flanked by high-ranking government officials, including Borlenghi and Gamboa, standing next to the charred flag, provided a vivid account of the dreadful event, further fueling emotions to a state of extreme agitation.

On Sunday, June 12, rumors spread that Peronist protesters planned to set fire to the Cathedral. In response to the gravity of the situation, groups from Argentine Catholic Action initiated a communication chain to alert the population and called for a rally in Plaza de Mayo to defend the main temple of the capital. Among the first to respond to the call was Florencio José Arnaudo, a young engineering student and rugby player for the Obras Sanitarias Club's first team, who also played a role in the clandestine publication "Verdad." Arnaudo, an exceptional individual with strong leadership qualities, chronicled those days in his book, "The Year the Churches Burned."

Arnaudo arrived at the square with several friends and connected with the organizers. Subsequently, the majority of Catholic Action members gathered on the steps of the Cathedral, prepared to face the unfolding events.

While conversing with a group of affiliates for about an hour, Arnaudo noticed a small column of Peronist protesters approaching the square, shouting, jumping, and chanting slogans in support of their leader. Among them were ordinary, humble residents from the suburbs, but Arnaudo also observed several thugs and provocateurs associated with the General Confederation of Labor. The presence of the latter saddened him more than angered him, and as he pondered the situation, someone urged the defense group to close ranks on the steps to prevent the approaching group from getting closer.

The newcomers yelled, "Clericals, oligarchs! They are all traitors and sell-outs!" The defense group grew in number with time, enough to halt the Peronist march.

As tension mounted, the Peronist demonstration grew in size, outnumbering the approximately one hundred opponents who stood firm with their arms folded and a defiant demeanor on the steps, maintaining their ranks.

-Perón, Perón! – they chanted as the situation became tense.
At that moment, Monsignor Manuel Tato left the Cathedral to give instructions and try to calm things down.

-Nobody say a word! – He ordered-Nobody move! We will only defend ourselves if we are attacked!


At that crucial moment, someone approached Arnaudo and warned him that individuals in gray raincoats (odd attire for a sunny day) were infiltrating the protesters. Arnaudo tried to reassure the informant but inwardly feared that they might be armed members of the Alianza Libertadora Nacionalista (ALN), a formidable justicialist shock force responsible for the fires of 1953 and several violent attacks against the opposition. Meanwhile, Monsignor Tato, in an effort to maintain control, repeatedly ordered the group not to react or make threatening movements unless the situation demanded it. Concerns grew as the first faithful started arriving for the afternoon mass.


Monsignor Manuel Tato

Completely aware of their protective role, the brave Catholic Action militants created gaps in their ranks, allowing the parishioners to pass through and swiftly closing them once they crossed the human fence they had formed.

Suddenly, a jeep carrying two members of the Alianza Libertadora Nacionalista appeared; one drove, while the other distributed flyers. The vehicle stopped in front of the Cathedral, and one of the individuals in a raincoat approached the occupants briefly. Arnaudo's suspicions were confirmed; these gray-clad men were indeed thugs from the group, ready to cause disturbances. However, Arnaudo chose not to raise alarms at that moment. As the tension grew, hours passed until 6:00 p.m. when the services concluded, and people began hurriedly leaving, with a few remaining inside. The decision was made to stand firm in the place.

By that time, the number of Peronists had significantly increased, surrounding their opponents who totaled around five hundred and sixteen people. Out of these, four hundred and thirty-four were men, mostly stationed outside on the steps of the temple, and the remaining sixty-five were women, along with the seventeen priests inside the Cathedral.

As insults and provocations escalated, a brick was thrown from the Peronist ranks, striking a defender in the face. The young blond boy tumbled down the steps, leaving a trail of blood. Shortly after, another Catholic militant fell backward, holding his head. His comrades lifted both wounded individuals and carried them inside the Cathedral while a barrage of stones, bricks, sticks, and bottles rained down on them.

"Inside! Everyone inside!" several voices shouted simultaneously, urging the defenders to retreat. 

Twenty wounded were taken into the Cathedral, entering through the main door, which remained open.

Arnaudo, ensuring everyone was covered, was the last to enter. Inside, numerous arms struggled to close the heavy doors, contending with the Peronists trying to open them from the outside. Gunshots were heard outside while an individual carrying an Argentine flag fought desperately to enter. Arnaudo approached and struck the stout man with thick glasses several times in the face, breaking his glasses and injuring his eye. Despite this, the man persisted and managed to enter, falling to the floor inside the Cathedral, where someone snatched the flag from him. A barrage of blows, sticks, and kicks rained down on him, almost leaving him unconscious.

"Hit him hard, he's from the Alliance!" someone yelled as the people continued to strike him. Fortunately, merciful hands intervened, moving the man to another part of the temple, sparing him from a potential lynching.

Meanwhile, in the atrium, the Peronists kept pressing to open the doors, and the defenders fiercely struggled to keep them closed.





Contrary to popular belief, the man with the glasses was not a member of the Peronist strike force but a Catholic militant named Pin Errecaborde, who had bravely snatched the flag from an attacker in order to protect it inside the temple. When Arnaudo learned the truth, he felt a deep sense of despair and guilt for his actions. Eager to make amends, he quickly inquired about Errecaborde's whereabouts and was directed to the sacristy, where the wounded were being cared for by some women.

In the sacred confines of the Cathedral, chaos reigned as the constant barrage of bricks, iron, and bottles striking against the doors and walls created an ear-splitting cacophony, and blood-curdling screams filled the air. At the entrances, a group of defenders struggled to unlock the main gate, which remained slightly ajar due to a jammed brick. Despite the combined strength of a dozen strong young men, the task proved insurmountable.

Fearing an attack from the Alliance, Arnaudo sprang into action and recklessly thrust part of his body outside to try and remove the obstacle. Unfortunately, a barrage of projectiles prevented him from succeeding. Meanwhile, another group of defenders, led by Humberto Podetti, broke the benches to arm themselves with clubs and prop up the doors. In the midst of the chaos, women rushed back and forth, tending to the wounded.

Eventually, the brick was dislodged, and the front door was closed, nearly coinciding with the voice of Father Menéndez giving instructions from the pulpit.

- Attention, everyone! Attention!

Upon hearing his call, several young people gathered around Arnaudo.

"We need to organize! We must establish order! Choose a leader!"


There was no doubt about it. Arnaudo was the obvious choice, given his stature, physical strength, and level-headedness. At their request, Arnaudo ascended the pulpit and rallied the defenders, directing them to form two groups—one to protect the temple and another to guard the Curia. He appointed Engineer Isidoro Lafuente as the leader of the former and Augusto Rodríguez Larreta, the leader of the Catholic Youth, to lead the latter. Immediately afterward, Arnaudo arranged for the women and wounded to stay in the sacristy. He then inquired if anyone had weapons, but Father Menéndez expressed their non-violent stance and confirmed that firearms were not present.

Despite this, four young men approached Arnaudo as he descended the pulpit steps and informed him that they were carrying weapons. One had a .32 caliber revolver, while the other two had .22 caliber pistols, and the fourth had a compressed air pistol. Though not an impressive arsenal, it was better than nothing.

Outside, the Peronists were attempting to force their way through the doors using a heavy object as a battering ram. Arnaudo quickly headed towards the Curia to assess the situation. On his way, he passed through the sacristy, where he saw several brave women tending to the wounded, some of whom were in critical condition. Despite the danger and the noise from the angry mob and shattered glass, the women continued their tasks with courage. As he crossed the patio, Arnaudo encountered Monsignor Tato, who was rushing to the temple from the Curia.

Inside the Curia, Engineer Lafuente, wounded in the head, was barricading doors and windows with the help of his cousins and dependents. Father Menéndez arrived shortly after, and Arnaudo asked him if there were other entrances to secure. The priest pointed out the garages, causing concern, as no one had noticed them. Arnaudo quickly rushed to the location and was horrified to find the Peronists attempting to break through the gates in the darkness.

- "Lafuente!" he yelled desperately, calling for Lafuente.
Lafuente hurried to the scene, but before he could take any action, several bricks crashed through the windows in that sector.

"We need to prop up the doors urgently!" Arnaudo exclaimed. A young Navy officer stepped forward, offering his assistance. "Take ten men immediately and shore up that entrance," Lafuente ordered, pointing to the garage entrances.

As the sailor left to follow the directive, Arnaudo armed himself with an improvised club and returned to the Curia's courtyard. A young man stopped him, sharing alarming news that ten thousand CGT workers were marching towards the location, armed and prepared for anything. In response, someone suggested ringing the bells, a proposal that everyone agreed upon. Several individuals rushed to the bell tower's door and, after finding it locked, Captain Eduardo García Puló gave it a powerful kick, causing it to swing open violently. The clamor of the battle now joined the ringing of the bells, a clear plea for help from the defenders.

The Peronists focused their attack on the Curia, believing it to be a vulnerable point of entry. Observers positioned by Arnaudo on rooftops and roofs noticed that the mob had commandeered a car and was using it as a battering ram to repeatedly strike the gates. In doing so, they set the gates on fire, causing the flames to spread towards the building. Members of the Alianza Libertadora Nacionalista and the CGT brandished their weapons and started shooting at anyone who appeared or passed through the openings of the Curia. To protect their lives, Arnaudo ordered all lights to be turned off and instructed everyone not to look outside, knowing that the assailants were shooting with lethal intent.

During this tense moment, a telephone in one of the adjoining rooms kept ringing incessantly. Despite the serious situation, a young boy nearby, thinking it might be an urgent call, opened the door and answered the phone. To his surprise, an anxious "package" lady asked if it was true that the Cathedral was on fire (2). This odd situation momentarily eased tensions and brought some laughter among the defenders. However, their respite was brief, as the Peronists intensified their assault.

Back in the sacristy, Arnaudo encountered Dr. Tomás Casares, a well-known Catholic militant and thinker, who continued to perform the functions of Minister of the Supreme Court of Justice at the express request of the ecclesiastical hierarchy. Casares informed Arnaudo that he had just spoken with the police authorities and the head of the Grenadier Regiment on Horseback, demanding their mediation.

"Listen to me, young man," the doctor said to Arnaudo, "as the one in command, if any authorities from the police or the Army arrive, you must notify me immediately, do you understand? Immediately!"

"Yes, Doctor!" Arnaudo responded.
At that point, it became evident that the efforts of the thousand assailants to seize the Cathedral were futile. The defenders, courageously led by Arnaudo, held their ground valiantly, while the Plaza de Mayo filled with onlookers who had come to observe the unfolding events.

Around 9:30 p.m., firefighters and policemen arrived—the former to control the fire and the latter to disperse the Catholic protesters gathered in San Martín and Diagonal Norte, who were demonstrating in support of Our Lord Jesus Christ, the Church, and freedom. At that precise moment, after three and a half hours of fighting, the attack ceased. The police approached the doors of the building to communicate with Monsignor Tato and Dr. Casares, while the defenders awaited expectantly inside the temple and the Curia.

Following the dialogue, Casares approached Arnaudo and informed him that everything was now over. The law enforcement officers would guard the place, and the defenders needed to hand over their weapons. Arnaudo and his brave comrades proceeded to deliver their "arsenal"—the .32 revolver, the two .22 pistols, and the compressed air pistol.

In the midst of these events, Arnaudo rushed to a telephone to call his father and notify him of what had happened (3). He also instructed his father to go to the library, retrieve the complete works of Chesterton, and destroy a piece of paper with addresses written on it.

He feared that during a potential raid later that day, this compromising "document" could be discovered, implicating everyone listed in it.

Almost at the same moment that Arnaudo was about to relinquish his position to a comrade, his friend and fellow student, Gastón Bordelois, who had recently been released from prison, approached him with a potential escape plan through the roofs. Arnaudo expressed gratitude for the information but felt it was his responsibility as the head of the defense to remain in his place. Nevertheless, he instructed Bordelois and his other friend, Humberto Podetti, to leave as soon as possible to continue editing "Verdad," their clandestine publication in opposition to Perón's persecution of the Church.

Despite their attempts, neither Podetti nor Bordelois managed to escape, as police officers blocked their way. Podetti returned to Arnaudo, but Bordelois managed to hide, avoiding detection.

During the turmoil, Monsignor Novoa led about fifteen boys to a secret room behind a false panel on the second level of the library, instructing them to remain hidden due to their compromised situations. Some were doing military service and belonged to the Military College and the Naval Academy. (4)

Around 11:00 p.m., Judge Carlos A. Gentile arrived with an arrest warrant for all the defenders, a move that Dr. Casares, who was trying to prevent going to jail, attempted to intercede against. However, his efforts were in vain.

"Abide by the order," he ordered with a sorrowful voice, addressing the defenders. "There is nothing more that can be done."
Monsignor Tato then asked the defenders to comply meekly and not create difficulties, assuring them that they would only be imprisoned for a few hours, as efforts to secure their release would begin shortly. At midnight, he invited everyone to receive Communion, not only to provide spiritual comfort to the brave souls but also to safeguard the Tabernacle and the consecrated hosts from potential desecration.

Men and women lined up, one by one, leaving the historic Cathedral—a tomb of the Liberator of America, the Unknown Soldier of their Independence, and a place of significant historical, artistic, and spiritual value (5). Inside police trucks, although satisfied with their fulfilled duty and comforted by Holy Communion, this small group of Spartans was taken to the National Penitentiary under severe custody and strict surveillance.

Notes

1 Years later actor, comedian and ephemeral priest.
 

2 Florencio Arnaudo, El año que quemaron las iglesias, Cap. XVII “La defensa de la Catedral”.
 

3 Ditto.
 

4 The room would disappear five days later when the Curia it was set on fire by angry mobs, after the aerial bombardment of the capital.

5 The women and priests were released after their names and document numbers were taken.

* Most of the information was taken from  El año que quemaron las iglesias, de Florencio Arnaudo and La Revolución del 55, Book I, Isidoro Ruiz Moreno.